Are Female Athletes More Prone to Recurrent Concussions?
A study set to be presented at the American Academy of Neurology's annual meeting (April 22-28, 2017, in Boston) finds that female athletes are 50% more likely to have a sports-related concussion than male athletes.
The analysis evaluated 1203 athletes (822 men and 381 women) who took part in sports such as soccer, basketball, and football at Columbia University between the years 2000 and 2014. Researchers administered tests to measure participants' thinking skills and processing speed before and after a concussion, in addition to tracking symptoms as well as the time elapsed before athletes returned to the playing fields after suffering a concussion.
Women May Recover More Slowly From Concussions
Same-Day Return to Game After Concussion is Still Common Among Child Athletes
Overall, a total of 228 athletes taking part in the study incurred at least 1 concussion during their college athletic career. Eighty-eight of these athletes (23%) were women, while 140 (17%) were men. According to the authors, women were twice as likely to suffer a concussion in comparison to men, while athletes who had experienced a previous concussion were 3 times more prone to have another concussion, compared to those who had never experienced a concussion. In addition, the researchers found that women were more likely to have had a concussion taking part in the gender-comparable sports of soccer and basketball.
"I don't think this study can necessarily inform risk mitigation strategies for concussion recurrence," said lead author James M. Noble, MD, MS, CPH, an assistant professor of neurology at Columbia University Medical Center, adding that "I have found this work helpful in my own practice, given that I treat similar members to the population studied."
While some of the lessons found in this study could be applicable in a primary care setting, "there may be inherent limits in generalizability of these findings," said Noble.
"Nonetheless," he added, "I do find this research to help in advising timelines and predictors of concussion, and [this study] compels us to consider a more conservative, yet always tailored, approach to return to play and return to learn strategies for our athletes."
Davis-Hayes C, Gossett J, Levine W, et al. Gender-specific outcomes and predictors of concussion recovery: a single site 15-year Ivy League experience [published online February 28, 2017]. AAN. https://www.aan.com/PressRoom/Home/GetDigitalAsset/12348.